Skip to main content

They Wish They Were Us

This one is really, really good. 

SUMMARY

After a tragic start to her high school career, Jill Newman is *finally* a senior. Walking into Gold Coast Prep, Jill's friend group since freshman year sits in the front row of each year's opening assembly. For the third year in a row since the death of Jill's dearest friend and most daring Player, Shaila Arnold is honored for her dazzling life before she was murdered by her boyfriend and former Player, Graham Calloway. 

At this point, you should probably know what a 'Player' is. A Player is the name for a member of the most elite social group at Gold Coast Prep. Senior Players choose the fittest and coolest freshman candidates for Players every year in the fall. The freshman candidates must prove their worth by performing 'pops' - near impossible challenges issued by the seniors to freshmen. The Players are an elite and tight-knit friend group (which is why the murder of Shaila Arnnold still rings in the group's ears); however, two facts are simple, but true and not good. (1) When the Players are out of school (and sometimes in school), they are always drunk. Always. Every pop, every party, every challenge, every sleepover, every game night is always supplied with an unhealthy amount of booze. (2) The Players cheat. With an entire app full of photocopied tests and asssessment answers, members are always top-notch students who all attend Ivy League universities. Man, constantly drunk + having good grades. Those reeeeeally go together. 

Graham did it, mudered Shaila, I mean. There's no question, right? He was covered in blood on the beach that night. He confessed. He must have. That's what everyone thought, until this year. This year, after all, was supposed to be different. Supposed to be more tame. Supposed to be less dangerous. Supposed to keep the fun comraderie and lose the drunk, reckless, hook-up culture. Jill realizes the Players will be no different this year, but Graham's guilt might be. 

REVIEW

While I expected this book to have a little more of a msyterious element to it, the ending had me reeling. As you all know, I've read enough books to call myself a conisseur in YA-mystery-ending-guessing (*hair flip*). I had no idea that this book would end in the manner it did. While reading I really never asked WHODUNIT? because I knew who. I got a big head a little bit; I'll admit it. To make a long sotry short (too late), you WON'T guess the ending of this book. The red herrings were just - MUAH - *chef's kiss*. 

The characters are vivid - the secret / not-so-secret society environment makes for designing and excuting larger than life charcters very natural. Even more enjoyable was the setting. Gold Coast is described impeccably: the quientessential East Coast rich town. Y'all, lil bookworm, innocent Hallie wanted to be a Player (until later, but you get what I mean). If my wish to be part of such a riske group doesn't tell you how well the Players are described, I don't know what will. 

I ate. this. book. up. Absolutely to die for. Well done, Jessica Goodman. They Wish They Were Us absolutely deserves the hype it receives. Must read this summer. FIVE BRIGHT STARS. 


*TW: Murder (it IS a murder mystery), grief, alcohol/drug (light) abuse, rape/sexual assault (light), sex
Age Range: 14/15+
ISBN: 9780593114292
Publisher: Penguin Young Readers Group (an imprint of Penguin Random House)
Tags: YA fiction, mystery, YA mystery, prep-school fiction, Jessica Goodman
Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Author Spotlight: Kimberly Brubaker Bradley

Kimberly Brubaker Bradley At my school, I am a Library Leader. (Library Leaders promote reading in the middle school and recommend books for the younger grades.) The Library Leaders had the fortunate opportunity of eating lunch and meeting with Kimberly Brubaker Bradley. We got to ask her questions and just talk with her. Mrs. Bradley also spoke to the whole seventh and eighth grade in assembly about her research. 1)      When/How does she write? Mrs. Bradley writes in the morning, but this depends on her chores for the day. She got into her routine when her children, now graduating college and out of college, were small and went to school. She would always wait until her husband took them to drop them off at school. She likes for her writing space to be very quiet. She prefers typing when she when she writes as to writing. (This may be pretty common; I do not know what the common format among writers is today. I just thought I would include eve...
Post a Comment
Read more

Long Way Down

A Long Way Down Written in verse, A Long Way Down by J ason Reynolds is a novel about making a moment’s decision. *DISCLAIMER: The story deals with grief, mild cussing, and gun violence. Plot Summary: Will doesn’t live in a so great part of town. This African-American teen’s brother, Shawn, is shot and killed by a member of gang member in a near-by part of town. Will decides to follow ‘The Rules’. (‘The Rules’ are passed on through generations of members of this community and they are: 1. DON’T CRY 2. NO SNITCHING 3. ALWAYS GET REVENGE.) Will decides to kill the gang member who killed Shawn. He HAS to follow ‘The Rules’. He gets on the elevator to go down to the Lobby and the elevator stops at every floor. People that have been shot in the past and were in his life get on the elevator at every floor. This thriller is written over one minute and nine seconds. Author Praise/Critique: Jason Reynolds is a very talented poet. The book is very visually pleasing because ...
Post a Comment
Read more

The 7 1/2 Deaths of Evelyn Hardcastle

Reading and writing, reading and writing, reading and writing: that's what I hope to keep doing all summer (with some swimming and seeing friends mixed in there too!). Here's another review! This is Stuart Turton's The 7 1/2 Deaths of Evelyn Hardcastle,  and it's a doozy.  SUMMARY THE RULES OF BLACKHEATH Evelyn Hardcastle will be murdered at 11:00 p.m. There are eight days and eight witnesses for you to inhabit. We will only let you escape once you tell us the name of the killer. Understood? Then let's begin... Evelyn Hardcastle WILL die. And every day Aiden Bishop WILL try to identify her killer and break this neverending cycle he has somehow found himself in. But every time a new day begins, Aiden inhabits the body of a different guest at Blackheath. Some of Aiden's hosts will be more helpful than others. Some of Aiden's hosts are more capable than others. Some of Aiden's hosts start to overcome Aiden's true personality. Then again, who is Aiden? A...
Post a Comment
Read more